Skip Nav

Prison doesn’t work – as the Glen Parva shambles shows

MOST READ NEWS

❶Much more money would also be needed to put in place comprehensive drug and alcohol treatment programmes that actually work.

Helping students improve writing skills since 2000!

Learn more
Top Headlines
Accessibility links

At the same time, with over 2. What are some ways that advocates and groups have combined pushing for immediate change in prison while also working towards abolition? For example, the prison abolitionist group Black and Pink , which advocates for and supports LGBTQ people behind bars, maintains close pen-pal relationships with prisoners, and sometimes takes further action, beyond writing letters, which is crucial in and of itself.

That action is based on what people are asking for. For instance, at one point, they were able to support a trans prisoner who was being denied her hormones — they did a big letter-writing campaigns and eventually she was granted access to hormones. And I think about how in Illinois, we were advocating for new mothers in prison to be able to breastfeed their babies during visits, and to use breast pumps, so they might be able to breastfeed when they got out.

Whether that was better food, more contact with the outside world, more time outside, more interaction. But part of abolition seems to be generally thinking creatively about how to address problems without calling in forces of the state. Because those forces so often exacerbate harm or cause harm, especially when directed at people of color.

Reach out and correspond with a pen pal in prison. Just this simple act of connection-building is a little step toward breaking down walls. And documenting — writing, photographing, making videos, making art — is also really important. My main form of acting against this system has been publishing and writing work that exposes the pain caused by prison and highlighting the work being done against it. There is wonderful work going on in this documentation department — but there is always a need for more.

Finally, advocating for health care, education, housing and other resources for all communities, especially the most marginalized, is a crucial part of abolition.

Real safety and real justice are only possible if everyone has what they need to live and thrive. This story was made possible by our members. Victoria Law is a freelance writer, analog photographer and parent.

She is the author of Resistance Behind Bars: Constitution, Declaration of Independence or the Federalist Papers. And virtually everyone in this nation is completely ignorant of it, as well as vulnerable to it! Dear People, The drug war is a fascist war against people, vulnerable people. It eviscerates the Constitution and Bill of Rights along with international human rights standards.

It reinstitutes slavery for multinational corporations via job-killing prison labor. And it further decimates disadvantaged people and at risk communities, while instituting a competitively alienating, anti-human predatory fascism that is one of the main drivers of our collective planetary mass suicide.

This barbarism and planet-killing inhumanity is the main reason why it is so many people resort to self-medicating drugs to survive it and the shocking depravity that accompanies it. We in Amerikkka are suffering from a deep unexplainable existential pain and loneliness, and the solution is drinking and drugging.

There are other alternatives than alienation for afflicted communities out there in the Amerikkkan nightmare, this waking nightmare we all share to a greater or lesser degree. It has to do with sharing burdens in our communities. Whatever cost-benefit analyses are presented to them, the public, or at least that vocal section of it whose cries for law and order make penal reform electoral suicide, resent this expenditure.

But anyway, it appears they don't really want prisoners rehabilitated, they want them punished. They want them locked down, maltreated and if it were possible beaten on a regular basis. They require convicted prisoners to be scapegoats for all that is wrong with society, while paradoxically desiring them to pay their debt to it, as if spending hours a day in a cell watching television could possibly equate with turning up for work, paying taxes and otherwise doing your bit.

These people erroneously believe that punishment works and point to the happily virtuous past to prove it. Certainly, if we go back a hundred years we find remarkably law-abiding citizenry and only 15, or so in prison as against today's ninety-odd, but perhaps this was because society for the lower orders, as they were then dubbed, was already a form of imprisonment?

There was little opportunity or energy to commit crimes when you were already doing hard labour for six-and-a-half days a week, nor was there any need for additional confinement when so much of the workforce was already banged-up below stairs.

The sort of nostalgia that attaches itself to the serialised class layer-cake that is Downton Abbey is of a piece with the refusal to recognise that grotesque inherited privilege is something people have struggled hard to do away with. Not without accident are our prison cess-pits nominally possessed by the Queen.

I'm not such a bleeding-heart liberal that I don't recognise the need for imprisonment when someone has been convicted of a violent crime, but unless an individual represents a credible physical threat I'd far rather he was set to work in the community to pay back what he has taken. In those cases where redistributive justice is impossible because the offender is already so socially inutile, their rehabilitation must consist precisely in assisting them to be the responsible citizen they have heretofore failed to become.

The raw meting out of punishment solves nothing. And although there are some psychopaths who may have to be confined indefinitely, the Manichaean belief in the unbridgeable rift between sanctity and evil that shadows so much of our thinking about prison should play no part in its actual administration, any more than should a belief in ghosts.

Four deaths have been linked to Florence, which has been downgraded to a tropical storm. A Point of View: Prisons don't work 7 October Previously in A Point of View. Top Stories US 'brute' of a storm turns deadly Four deaths have been linked to Florence, which has been downgraded to a tropical storm. Young kids are kept in prison to long, and they learn from other criminals. When they are paroled, they are better criminals, and they won't get caught as easily.

How is jail working if criminals are being released better at their crimes from when they were first sentenced to imprisonment? Conservative lawmakers want to try kids as young as thirteen in adult courts, and they are trying to place them in adult prisons. Although juvenile crime has become more pervasive and more violent , it is not fair to lock up young kids with hardened criminals.

This will not lower the crime-rate, but just increase the prison population. While in these hardcore prisons, teenagers would be getting a criminal education instead of a real education. Politicians claim that they support policies that are tough on crime and prisons, but they're not. In "Why Prisons Don't Work", even Rideau said it himself, "If getting tough on crime resulted in public safety, Louisiana citizens would be the safest in the nation.

Louisiana has the highest murder rate among states. Instead of putting money into programs such as remedial education, psychiatric counseling, drug treatment, or vocational training, the government would rather put money into prisons.

Some prisoners have the luxury of state of the art computers, the convenience of the Internet, and the pleasure of television. While schools are just now getting new computers with access to the Internet, prisoners have already had this pleasure of easy access to state of the art equipment.

Rehabilitation can work, but until prisons do more for rehabilitation prisoners won't change. The convict who enters prison illiterate will probably leave the same way. That is over half! To be able to change you must have something to look forward to when you are released.

When I was a young child, my best friend's dad was in prison. I was too young to remember the crime or the sentence, but he did have to spend a lot of time in prison. While in prison, he knew that he had a beautiful wife and two wonderful daughters waiting for him at home.

The Conversation

Main Topics

Privacy Policy

This essay has been submitted by a law student. This is not an example of the work written by our professional essay writers. Does Prison Work? Introduction. Prisons, most commonly known as correctional institutions, have been an integral part of Criminal Justice System along with Police and the Courts (Griffiths, 3).

Privacy FAQs

Originally written for a competition by the Howard League for Penal Reform for essays on the topic of “Why Prisons Don’t Work”. You can read the winning (and excellent) essays here. It is often said “prison works”. It is less often said what it means for a prison to “work”.

About Our Ads

Prison Does Work Based on research done by many authors, scholars, criminologists, sociologists, various survey agencies, some evidence has been presented on success of prisons. They argue that prisons are effective. Possible Reasons why Prison Doesn’t Work Firstly, most (as in about two thirds) have no qualifications and many prisoners have the reading age of a 10 year old when they go into jail – and lack of educational programmes in jail does little to correct this.

Cookie Info

Do Prisons Work essaysPrison life is mostly a continuous repetition of the same day, over and over again. Finding a purpose and a meaning beyond "punishment" can be a struggle. Often people are not in prison long enough to discover anything worthwhile beyond a new set of criminal alliances. More about Do Prisons Work Essay example. Prisons Don't Work Essay Words | 6 Pages; How Prison Life Really Works Essay Words | 6 Pages; Why Prisons Don't Work- Wilbert Rideau Essay Words | 4 Pages; Why Do People Do Volunteer Work Words | 24 Pages; It Is Often Stated That Prison Does Not Work Because of the High Recidivism Rates.