Skip Nav

Speech Critiques

The Most Important Thing to Analyze: The Speech Objectives

❶Who Should Read It Everyone who writes, whether speeches, novels, or articles. Equally, the vocal variety he exhibits is worthy of emulation.

Why use video critiques?

The Audience and Context for the Speech
Legal Stuff
Why study other speakers?

This cleverly crafted phrase is spoken multiple times at Though Pink could lessen his finger wagging, his body language and gestures use throughout the speech are excellent. He manages to match his gestures and movements to the large venue. One cannot watch without realizing his enthusiasm and energy, which comes out strongly.

An example, of this is shown when he indicates the low, the medium, and the high rewards using his hand. If for instance, this was a usual, PowerPoint presentation, probably a chart could have been used.

Conversely, he exhibits that the most significant visual is the speaker. Equally, the vocal variety he exhibits is worthy of emulation. He uses varied pace, pauses, emphasis and volume excellently. When appropriate, walk around the stage instead of leaning against a podium.

Listen for filler words. Listen for these words and make a note of how many times you hear them. While saying a few filler words is natural, they should not overwhelm the speech or be noticeable in any way.

See if the speech was memorized. A great speaker should have memorized the speech long in advance. Using a typed page of notes or using powerpoint to jog one's memory is acceptable, but glancing down too many times can be distracting for audience members. It was once acceptable to carry a series of notecards and read from them, but this is no longer the case. Assess how the speaker manages anxiety. Most people suffer from stage fright.

Public speaking is the second worst fear in North America, ranking above death. Look for signs that the speaker is nervous so you can offer a critique that will help him or her improve next time. Note any repeated movements or gestures that take away from the content of the speech; these could be signs of nervousness. A shaky voice or tendency to mumble are also signs of nervousness.

Take detailed notes during the speech. Bring a notebook and pen to the speech, so you can make note of areas that need improvement. Being as detailed as possible in your notes will help the speaker understand exactly what to work on for next time.

If there are no restrictions against it and you have time, record the speech using either a video camera or a tape recorder. This way, you will have the opportunity to play back the speech more than once to get an idea of what point the speaker was making, as well as how well they said it. Include examples to back up your evaluation of each. Deconstruct the speech by part, starting with the introduction and ending with the conclusion. Give an overall evaluation of whether you felt the main points of the speech were adequately presented and reinforced, and whether you felt the speech as a whole seemed convincing and credible.

Would you consider it a successful speech, or does it need to be revised? Tell the speaker what elements of the speech were interesting, which parts were confusing, and which areas need more references to back them up.

Tell the speaker whether you felt the speech was appropriate for the intended audience. Give the speaker a gentle but honest critique of the effectiveness of his or her body language and delivery, including tone of voice, pacing, eye contact, and posture. It might be helpful to discuss the concept of emotional intelligence , or EQ, which refers to the ability to read an audience and keep people engaged by affecting their emotions. Helping them feel included will make them more likely to stay engaged.

If the speaker seemed nervous, you might suggest that he or she practice techniques that help reduce stage fright, like exercising before the speech, laughing before the speech and practicing in front of a small group of people first. Point out the positive, too. Try the feedback sandwich technique: This classic way to deliver constructive criticism makes the medicine go down more easily. For example, you could tell the person he or she started with a brilliant hook, but you were confused about how the second point related to the thesis.

However, the conclusion clarified the main point. As a way to encourage the person to keep learning and improving, you might suggest he or she watch videos of speeches given by famous speakers. A speech critique should balance between being proper, organized, and professional. Not Helpful 1 Helpful Similarly, different techniques will be applied when communicating with teenagers as opposed to communicating with corporate leaders.

The content of the speech should be selected and organized to achieve the primary speech objective. Focus is important — extraneous information can weaken an otherwise effective argument. Due to the primacy effect , words, body language, and visuals in the speech opening are all critical to speaking success. Like the opening, the words, body language, and visuals in the speech conclusion are all critical to speaking success. This is due to the recency effect. Delivery skills are like a gigantic toolbox — the best speakers know precisely when to use every tool and for what purpose.

Sometimes, a technically sound speech can still miss the mark. Likewise, technical deficiencies can sometimes be overcome to produce a must-see presentation. The intangibles are impossible to list, but here are a few questions to consider:. The next article in this series — The Art of Delivering Evaluations — examines how best to utilize speech evaluation skills as a teaching tool.

This is one of many public speaking articles featured on Six Minutes. Subscribe to Six Minutes for free to receive future articles. I absolutely loved this article. It gave me a major idea of what to write on my speech critique. Great information, organized, and detailed! I have to say, it was when I started to do exactly what you say that my skills took off.

If anyone wants to go farther, just teach a class on public speaking. You do not need a degree to teach continuing ed. It will help you, as some of my students who went on to teach to improve even more. This is because not only are you observing your students for these points. You are actually teaching them how to attain some of these skills. Your article is very informative. Hope you post more tips on writing a speech and how to analyse it!!

Thanks for providing this information. I am writing an essay critiquing my own speech in third person. A tough task, but these pointers made it easier. Will be very much helpful when i have to do evaluations for speech class!

Great job once again! I liked the clarity with which these concepts were explained. Self explanatory and useful for both novice and advanced speakers. Best article I found for speech critique and analysis. Definitely a place to come back for speech resource.


Main Topics

Privacy Policy

On November Monday 17, Arnold Schwarzenegger gave his inaugural speech as the newly sworn in Governor of California. Standing at the podium in his expensive three piece suit with his dutiful wife standing behind him he thanked the citizens for believing in him and giving him a chance to fix 3/5(7).

Privacy FAQs

Unlike most editing & proofreading services, we edit for everything: grammar, spelling, punctuation, idea flow, sentence structure, & more. Get started now!

About Our Ads

Essays - largest database of quality sample essays and research papers on Speech Critique. Critique a public speech essaysOn Sunday mornings I attend my church. The preacher this past Sunday spoke on Our Relationship with God. The purpose of the sermon was to convey to the congregation that it is important to have a relationship with God. The Pastor explained to us our relationship with.

Cookie Info

Free speech analysis papers, essays, and research papers. Speech Analysis Essay. The puzzle of motivation by Dan Pink (TED ) Pink delivers a very well organized speech. He opens the speech very strongly when he states- "I need to make a confession ” – creating a mystery and drawing the audience in instantly.